Status

Kept by the program lead (agents/program-lead.md). Last updated 21 Nov 2026.

PhaseStateNext stepOwner
Decisions, board invitesOpenBob and Ken: review board names, launch languages, home, licenceBob, Ken
Repo and truth checksDone (15 Nov)Keep CI greenClaude
Level 100 objective mapSigned 16 Nov: Ken Johnston, by proxy (Ken gave his proxy to Bob, who approved). 11 modules, Big Widget Company, three yesesNone: modules can be written against itKen
Level 100 manuscript and case bankDone: science passages in 100.1–100.4 checked 17 Nov by a separate checker, 29 of 29 supported (levels/100/drafts/source-check.md); case bank updated 18 Nov for Bob's anchor decisionsNoneBob, Ken
Placement test, viewerLive with 11 Level 100 lessons and 22 placement items; published lessons carry the public stamp and no draft bannerKeep CI greenDevin
Write, check, red-teamDone (18 Nov): 11 modules written, source-checked by separate sessions, red-teamed to 0 open findingsErrata and freshness checks weeklyClaude, Devin
Human review, sign-offDone 18 Nov 2026: Bob Rapp (subject) and Ken Johnston (audience, relayed by Bob) approved all 11; Bob Rapp red-team lead; board signed by Ken Johnston by proxy (levels/100/decisions-2026-11-18.md, levels/100/board.yml)None: Level 100 is publishedBob, Ken
Level 200Published 20 Nov 2026 on Bob Rapp's publish yes (levels/200/decisions-2026-11-20.md): 10 modules, two human reviewers each, board signed by Ken Johnston by proxy (levels/200/board.yml)Errata and freshness checks weeklyBob, Ken
Level 300Published 20 Nov 2026 on Bob Rapp's publish yes (levels/300/decisions-2026-11-20.md): 11 modules, two human reviewers each, board signed by Ken Johnston by proxy (levels/300/board.yml); 300.R cert-prep rails not clearedErrata and freshness checks weeklyBob, Ken
Level 400Published 20 Nov 2026 on Bob Rapp's publish yes (levels/400/decisions-2026-11-20.md): 12 modules, two human reviewers each, board signed by Ken Johnston by proxy (levels/400/board.yml); prep rails not clearedErrata and freshness checks weeklyBob, Ken
Level 500Published 20 Nov 2026 on Bob Rapp's publish yes (levels/500/decisions-2026-11-20.md): 11 modules, two human reviewers each, board signed by Ken Johnston by proxy (levels/500/board.yml); prep rails not clearedErrata and freshness checks weeklyBob, Ken
Pilot cohortNot startedAfter 100 is signedFo, Ken

Merges and open items (21 Nov 2026)

Devin is out of tokens. Until it is back, Claude covers the builder and program-lead roles. The red-team role runs under Bob's 21 Nov 2026 exception to TRUTH-STANDARD rule 3, not paused as it was earlier that day: rule 3 wants a different system from the writer, and the lessons are written by Claude. A Claude session may red-team what it did not write, edit or source-check; every such report is headed as a same-system red team with a re-test by a different system pending; the human red-team lead still rules on every finding; and the exception is reviewed when Devin is back or on Bob's word (design/decisions-2026-11-21-bob.md, #128).

Merged on Bob's instruction, 21 Nov: #109 (Bob and Ken's 20 Nov decisions), #43, #48, #91, #94 (Level 100, 200, 300, 500 art), #95, #96, #97 (viewer progress, accessibility CI, freshness and erratum guard), #98 (Level 100 spaced review), #93 (deep review), #123 (CC BY-NC 4.0 licence), #124 (visual reviewer role), #121 (red-team auditor), #111 (credentials), #122 (certificate design with a hex band; signatory titles "Founder and Co-chair, Review Board"). The "Devin Review" status on these never completed because Devin is out of tokens.

Merged later on 21 Nov, also on Bob's instruction: #127 and #129 (Level 100 1.0.1 and 1.0.2 errata), #137 (Bob re-signs the five 1.0.2 rows), #131 (the Levels 100-500 visual review), #132, #133, #134 (the level openers: proxy credit, a text equivalent each, and the 640-canvas redraw that makes them readable on a phone), #135 (the viewer places teaching figures in the lesson), #138 (Bob's V-5 and V-6 rulings), #140 (a step list beside all 23 workflow diagrams), #141 (two stale placement lines), #128 (Bob's 21 Nov answers and the red-team exception), #142 (this file brought current) and #136 (the Level 500 and 200-500 art red-team audit, rulings outstanding). "Devin Review" did complete on the later ones.

Builder fixes made along the way: main merged into #48, #91, #98 and #122, with the art-plan (#48), viewer (#98) and credentials (#122) conflicts resolved keeping both sides; CI's checks and browser jobs now fetch full Git history, and the site-build tests copy .git, so the errata gate can publish a module's last signed snapshot while an erratum waits for a re-sign.

ItemStateNext stepOwner
Level 100 errataDone 21 Nov: #127 published 1.0.1 for six modules, then #129 and #137 took five of them to 1.0.2 with Bob's re-signatures (levels/100/decisions-2026-11-21.md). Versions now: five modules at 1.0.2, 100.3 at 1.0.1, the other five at 1.0.0NoneBob, Claude
Level 100 gear status linesFixed in #129: each gear's status line now gives its module's current version, so the five at 1.0.2 say so. 100.3 carries no status lineNoneBob
#98 draft review items35 items in levels/100/review-sets.json stay out of the buildEach module's two reviewers approve themReviewers
#121 follow-upBob ruled AU1 and AU2 on 21 Nov as unclear, no fix required (#128). The fresh session's audit of Level 500 and the 200–500 art merged on Bob's instruction, 21 Nov (#136, 3bf0b0d): 15 reports, 34 findings, every ruling cell blank — 33 unclear, 1 misleading, recommendations split between re-test and human ruling needed. By report: Level 500 art 5, 400 art 4, 300 art 4, 200 art 1, the 11 Level 500 modules 20. Merging recorded the reports and ruled on nothingRed-team lead rules on the 34 findings. Two the audit calls substantive: 500.3 AU2 (the gears say the signed receipt holds who decided; 500.2 teaches that a key id names the key, not a person) and 300 art AU1 (the 300.9 caption still says the holder renews expired approval)Bob
Visual review round 2Open as #139, appended to the round-1 files so no recorded ruling is overwritten. Audited at d14f275, so its V-5 rows read as open although #140 closed themBob reads it; ruling cells blank by designBob
#111 follow-upCredentials mergedPages repo, DNS and key ceremony at verify.aigovops.orgBob
Quiz option length (rule 10)Open, and the largest item on this list. Always picking the longest option scores 81% at Level 100 (101 of 124 keys; 22 are placement items); always the shortest scores 35% at Level 500. 26 of 55 modules are over the one-third cap and check_modules.py warns on each (docs/reviews/2026-11-21-option-length.md)Item writer rebalances, placement items first; each module needs an erratum and a re-sign; the red team re-attacks the changed items. Make the check block when the warnings reach zeroBob, item writer
Teaching figures and art toolsBob's four decisions of 21 Nov (design/decisions-2026-11-21-art-tools.md): figures stay SVG; scene art may use Gemini's image models, Devin the alternative; Gemini reviews as a different model; narration is to be considered before a large figure programme. 54 teaching figures cover 344 sections; a pilot took 100.6 from one to five (#156)Bob looks at #156 and answers its four questions. Image generation needs billing on the Gemini keyBob, Claude
Workflow step lists (visual review V-5)Done 21 Nov on Bob's ruling: all 23 workflow diagrams carry a figure-text/ step list, and tools/module_figures.py now requires one on every teaching figureNoneClaude